Learn to Love Feedback: It’s Your Career Currency

Never flinch at failure: If you’re not making some mistakes, you’re not doing anything – not trying to make things happen. Mistakes are part of winning – not dumb mistakes or those caused by haste and sloppiness but mistakes made by intelligent and thoughtful individuals attempting to make something happen.”
—John Wooden in The Essential Wooden (click here to read my Essential Wooden book notes)

People often seem to feel attacked by feedback, when in reality it’s one of the single most effective ways to improve your performance. Wooden’s entire philosophy was built around meticulous observation and feedback of the teams he coached. Wooden says, “Perfection is imposible. Capitalizing on imperfection – mistakes – makes all the difference.”

For this reason, I think of feedback as career currency – a valuable commodity that can make a big difference in your performance. While feedback can be hard to hear at times, I like to think it shows that person cares about my development – and that’s a good thing. I don’t want to be the person walking around with proverbial food in my teeth all day, with no one caring enough to point it out.

Your goal should be to collect as many pieces of feedback as you can over the course of your career – from managers AND peers. I believe that the ability to gracefully receive feedback, and subsequently change that behavior, is a key distinguishing factor for star performers. Good feedback will help you improve and adjust to your environment more quickly than you could do on your own – so treat it like gold and grow that bank account!

5 things I’ve learned about feedback:

  1. Continuous, constructive feedback makes you rich. It accelerates your learning and development and will often lead to improved relationships and potentially faster career progression.
  2. We’re often unaware of our own blind spots. For example, imagine yourself as a Starbucks barista: What if you could make a latte twice as fast if someone showed you how? Wouldn’t you want to know? You may never have figured out those new techniques without feedback from another observer.
  3. Ask! Let people know that you’re open to feedback. Don’t argue or get defensive when they do give feedback – just say thank you. You can decide later (on your own time) what you want to take or leave from that feedback.
  4. Give! In the spirit of helping others, practice giving them feedback too. Be specific about behaviors, not just the tasks or the work itself. For example, someone tells you “great presentation!” and another says “Great composure and eye contact during that presentation.” Which version would you find more helpful?
  5. Need help delivering clear feedback? Try the EAR formula: Event, Action, Result. For example: During the meeting last week (EVENT), you were biting your nails (ACTION) and the result was that you appeared nervous, which may have left the wrong impression on our clients (RESULT).

How to Start Growing Your Feedback Account

Below is a 4-Step Feedback Recipe from my friends at Rypple (a free web 2.0 feedback service) to help you be more intentional about getting feedback:

  1. Set a goal: what do you want to accomplish or develop? e.g. I want to improve my communication skills.
  2. Build an adviser network: pick a group of advisers who can help you achieve your goal.
  3. Request feedback: ask your advisers short, focused questions, frequently to continuously reveal actionable insights.
  4. Commit to action: ACT on the feedback you get! Sharing those actions with your adviser network will motivate you and keep you on track.

Click here to learn more about Rypple, set-up an advisor network, create a development plan, or start getting feedback!

28 comments

Categories: CareerWork

  • http://www.ryanjknapp.com Ryan Knapp

    I was one who definitely didn't value feedback and felt it was a personal attack. I still kinda feel that way but I've grown to accept it more and realize that they aren't criticizing me, but they are trying to help me become better.

    John Wooden is an amazing guy, love reading his books!

  • http://www.emilyjasper.com/ Emily Jasper

    I know for me, when I was in sales, I was always asking clients how I could improve our relationship. I did this with everyone, especially clients who weren't bringing in my big numbers. I found that in demonstrating that I wasn't going to take feedback “personally,” the clients were open with me. We could make adjustments that benefited everyone, and feelings weren't part of the picture. Thanks for the post!

  • http://twitter.com/ddebow ddebow

    What I find strange is how many people view asking for feedback as a sign of weakness or excessive need for validation, when the exact opposite it true. As you point our high-performers are constantly trying to find out how they can do better – and ask people lots of questions, enlist coaches and mentors, etc.

    So, its surprising that the behavior of the top people is considered to be 'weak' by so many. What do you think is behind this? How can we change this mindset?

  • http://3monthsforward.blogspot.com/ Laura

    I like the analogy of career currency. Getting actually feedback can be extremely useful and I think I am getting better at taking advantage of of. What I sometimes find difficult is giving that constructive feedback to someone without sounding like I am picking on them. I tend to use generalities and hope they get the hint but that's not very effective!

    Also, I like the EAR acronym… perhaps another google doc?

  • http://25andtrying.com Beth Oppenheim

    Loved this advice, I really think that feedback is lacking a lot in the traditional workplace sometimes (at least in the nonprofit sector where I am). Since I have been in the workforce, which is approximately 4 years since college, I have not had a single performance review – despite asking for a formal one! I strive for excellence, but there's no real weight or measure. I like the communal aspect of feedback, and really love when people give me feedback on my blog or my work in general. Great great ideas.

  • http://www.theemotionmachine.com/criticism-and-goal-achieving The Emotion Machine

    Fantastic advice! Criticism can either build us up or tear us down depending on our perspective. Earlier this year I actually wrote a short guide on how to discern good criticism from bad. If you or anyone is interested they can click my name and it will take you to the article. Thanks again and keep it up with the blog! I join the “life after college” club in about 2 1/2 weeks!

  • Pingback: Feedback as Career Currency – Rypple

  • http://www.emilyjasper.com/ Emily Jasper

    I know for me, when I was in sales, I was always asking clients how I could improve our relationship. I did this with everyone, especially clients who weren’t bringing in my big numbers. I found that in demonstrating that I wasn’t going to take feedback “personally,” the clients were open with me. We could make adjustments that benefited everyone, and feelings weren’t part of the picture. Thanks for the post!

  • readytofeedback

    Great article and comments that show the potential for feedback to inspire, if done well and frequently. Jenny, great recommendations for helping people do that. You too, are indeed, a Feedback Enthusiast! Happy to find you.

    The ability to offer and ask for feedback shows the world that you are in control of your emotions to make yourself and others around you better. Based on my experiences, feedback is often seen as an opportunity to “criticize past performance”, instead of “empowering future performance”.

    Marshall Goldsmith has coined the term “FeedForward” to help change this perception. Offering and asking for feedback creates powerful, wonderful opportunities to learn about yourself and help others celebrate and improve.

    How we approach feedback is largely based on how we've been exposed to it in the past. My mission is to help people offer and ask for powerful inspiring feedback. Are you Ready to Feedback? Jenny, thanks for sharing in my passion.

    Sonia Di Maulo, Feedback Enthusiast
    http://www.readytofeedback.com

  • http://twitter.com/AJ_Bingham A.J. Bingham

    Thanks for sharing those points! We can only go stronger by building up our weaknesses. One of my biggest professional frustrations was not getting timely, and quality, feedback.

    I'll implement these as I go forward. Thank you!

  • jenniewhite

    I have to agree with Ryan; until recently I felt feedback as a personal attack. That stuff they tell us about Gen Y being praised for everything they do applies to me and it's been tough to break away from that. I have always been a hard worker and have been complimented the whole way through. Until recently, I've taken on some new projects and constructive criticism has come with those projects.

    I like how you said it's the people who care that will give you feedback. They are the people that are invested enough in you to make sure you succeed.

    Jenny, I swear to god you read my mind. All of your posts relate directly to what is going on in my life. Craziness. Congrats on the #1 Gen Y Blog as well!

  • jenniewhite

    Forgot the most important thing! I am totally going to start growing my feedback account. It's time.

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Hey Ryan! Yes – I definitely think it's a learning process. I still find myself bracing the chair when I'm getting ready to hear feedback, but afterward I'm thankful to have new information to help me improve.

    And I'm with you on the Wooden fan club – go bruins!

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Emily – I think that “how can I improve the relationship?” is a GREAT question – thanks for sharing. And so true that asking for feedback (and showing through action that you are open to it) paves the way for more direct, honest communication. I can imagine this approach has helped you be really successful. Thanks for stopping by!

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Daniel – thanks for stopping by! I think it takes some of the stigma away when managers make it a practice to regularly deliver feedback (good and “bad”) and regularly ask for it in return.

    For example – I had one manager who put “feedback” as a standing agenda item on our 1:1s. Right after we started our meetings, both of us had a chance to deliver and receive feedback. It was a great way to show that feedback can (and should) be a regular part of our jobs.

    Thanks again for all the great work you and the team are doing at Rypple – it's been fun keeping up with all of you :)

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Thanks for stopping by Laura! As a “people pleaser” I've definitely had a hard time delivering feedback in the past. As someone once told me, there is a way to deliver it with a “soft heart” so the other person knows it comes from a place of caring. As long as you are authentic and honest (and not trying to force yourself to word it in a specific way), I think feedback can land well.

    And yes – i agree that generalities can often lead to confusion – if you have specific examples, better to share them than hold back.

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Hey Jennie! You are great – I love that you are going to start growing your feedback account :)

    So true that when we are used to praise it can be really tough to hear constructive criticism. I just try to remember that they are telling me how to improve because they care about me – and want me to grow into an even more productive employee (for which I'm game). Even if the feedback stings at first, I find that usually wears off and I can make some really positive changes to the way I work. Sounds like you are definitely doing the same!

    And thanks so much for the congrats on the Gen Y Blog list! I really appreciate you being a reader and leaving comments – they make me smile :)

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Thanks so much for stopping by, A.J! I think building upon our weaknesses AND enhancing our existing strengths and talents make for a powerful combination. I hear you about being frustrated by not getting timely, high quality feedback. I think the timely aspect is key – it's not helpful to hear something 3 or 6 months after the fact in a performance review. Thanks again for your comment – have a great day!

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Thanks so much, Beth! I agree – I think people really shy away from giving feedback because they are trying so hard to be “nice.” Well, the nice thing is to tell people how to improve – especially if you can see specific ways for them to do that. I can't even imagine how frustrated you must be after not having ANY performance reviews in four years, despite asking for one! You might really enjoy Rypple – it's a great way to get feedback from your peers (and people outside of your company) – in lieu of people at work being willing to deliver it.

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Thanks! You are so right – it is all about our perspective. I really liked the post you linked to – highly recommend others check it out as well.

    And let the countdown begin for joining the Life After College club – so exciting!

  • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

    Hi Sonia – Thanks so much for stopping by and for leaving such a great comment. Here's to being a fellow Feedback Enthusiast! I love what you said about using feedback to “empower future performance” – what a great way to think about it.

  • yourhumblescribe

    Be quick but don't hurry.

  • yourhumblescribe

    Be quick but don't hurry.

  • http://www.jobsindubai.com/ UAE Jobs

    test

  • http://www.jobsindubai.com/ UAE Jobs

    Feedback's regarding with your career can be very useful for you will be able to avoid mistakes, even though mistakes are just natural there are still some ways to avoid making one

  • Pingback: 20/20 – Day 1: 20 ways to engage with feedback « TheUniversityBlog

  • Alison Grimaldi

    I enjoyed reading this article, I also felt that it gave me great insight as to handle new job environments and opportunities. I often get defensive over feedback because hey, lets be honest here, the truth hurts sometimes. This article gave me a new appreciation for feedback. Another blogging website, The Next Great Generation, also know as TNGG, also involves many articles in which the generation Y, or Millenials, write articles on a large range of topics, including some insight as to life after college. http://www.thenextgreatgeneration.com/2010/05/2

  • Pingback: How can I be better?

Previous post:

Next post: