Stuck like glue? Enter the Pining Prevention Plan.

Last December, during the magical week in which my friend Julie and I realized we simply had to move to New York, I met a guy.

He will be hereto referred to as The Guy, so as to protect the innocent, though the only one about to be embarrassed by this post is me. Now I’m just crossing every finger and toe, hoping he doesn’t actually read my blog!

Wherein I make myself sound like Debbie Desperate:  

Exhibit A: Me and my NYC-Angel Ann, on the night I met The Guy.

It was a snowy Saturday night at The Standard Hotel in the Meatpacking district, and I was all dressed up because I had just attended my NYC Angel Ann’s 40th birthday party. See Exhibit A. 

I’m not sure how The Guy and I started talking, but we didn’t stop until 5am. And no, not “talking” as a euphemism; ACTUAL talking. With words and stuff.

We talked about life, big dreams, grand career ambitions, side hustling while working corporate jobs, taking risks, tough financial decisions, and creating a location independent lifestyle. After last call at the bar, we moved into the lounge — ordered water and a grilled cheese sandwich — and the conversation continued.

I was smitten.

He was handsome, tall, athletic, intelligent, successful and humble. The Guy and I hung out a few times that week, then it was time for me to head back to California. I expected all communication to end, given that we lived on opposite coasts, but I was secretly hoping it wouldn’t.

During the week that we hung out, he was mysterious. A little hard to follow. I was never sure how interested he was. On a scale of 1-10, it could have easily been a 2 or an 8. After I got home, we did end up texting a little bit. I found myself thinking about him all the time.

The other day I joked that I’m dating my blog.

I haven’t had a serious boyfriend since I started getting serious about my blog and book — so, if you do the math, it’s been a little over 3 years. Apparently I’m even pickier than I am busy! So when someone gets my attention — really grabs it with chemistry and conversation — I’m hard-pressed to let go. This is a flaw.

It’s a flaw because I’m big on being treated with respect; but in a pining state, I accept so much less than what makes me happy. I settle for scraps – a text message here, a three-day (or three-week) wait time on the next reply there – and somehow project that things could still work out.

I tried forgetting about The Guy. Hard.

Do you know how many times I’ve been back to NYC since I met him? 3 times, including a one month stint. I still wonder about him every single time I’m there. I think about him when I’m out at night; when the conversations disappoint me and I wonder when I’ll feel that excited about someone again. Which is crazy, since he didn’t seem all that excited about me.

We hung out once when I was back there in May, but every sign in the universe (and my non-ringing phone) said, “He’s just not that into you.”

Note: If you haven’t read my post Love & Limerence (with Break-up Template), that is a MUST. It explains the crazy “addicted to crack” feeling that love and it’s crush cousin create.

Back in December I made a list of questions in my journal that I felt would help me work through the pining:

  • The shame of wanting something that so clearly would be nothing
  • Feeling crazy about obsessing over someone without it being reciprocated
  • Identifying the gap between fantasy and actual reality
  • Disappointment at not being able to move on

For the last seven months the questions have only lived in my journal for two reasons: a) I was debating when to embarrass myself by sharing this story, and b) I wasn’t sure if it would actually be helpful. But alas, as with most things, I’d rather put it out there and let you all be the judge.

{Check out the Pining Prevention Plan template

This is more of a reflection exercise than a template — and to be honest, it won’t PREVENT pining (I’d surely become a millionaire!) it will hopefully just help alleviate it. I just couldn’t resist that great 3P alliteration…can you blame me?

The questions will help you work through your pining and hopefully see your situation in a new light that helps you move on. It will work even better if you have a friend who can help you talk through the answers to each of the questions.

It’s still a MAJOR work in progress, so from those who try it, I would love to know:

Is it helpful? What other questions should I ask?
What helps you move on from someone when it’s clear things won’t work out?

And finally,

How on Earth can one person who we can’t have (or forget) drive us so damn crazy?!

Okay fine, that last one is rhetorical. ;)

***

P.S. Make sure you actually visit my blog next week….the new redesign launches, baby! It will be the first time in SIX years that the logo and tagline will be updated (from when I designed my website myself in 2005) — among making everything else prettier too. Thank you Nina Cross!

P.P.S. If you’re not already, sign-up for my Inside Scoop behind-the-scenes monthly newsletter and you’ll get access to my Organized Like a Ninja Tooklit and 15 (!!) kick-ass templates for every area of your life.

  • http://www.opheliaswebb.com Elisa Doucette

    “I accept so much less than what makes me happy. I settle for scraps – a text message here, a three-day (or three-week) wait time on the next reply there – and somehow project that things could still work out.”

    GET OUT OF MY HEAD.

    Oh wait. This is probably due to the fact that we had this conversation this weekend, huh?

    So, when are we SP-ing over this worksheet? Cause honey, yes.  :)

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      I’m calling you as soon as I get off the phone with AWeber, so basically, YOU JUST READ MY MIND!!!!!

      We must SP about all things Pining, emails, templates and secret BFF notes sent via Picasa (<3)

      Talk soon!!

  • http://twitter.com/amandaabella Amanda Abella

    I can relate to this entirely. I haven’t had a serious boyfriend since I decided to take myself and my dreams seriously. I’m practically married to my blog/career/writing.

    And I ended up pining over some jerk for a long time. Two years I’ll never get back. *Sigh*

    The good news is blogs don’t talk back or cheat lol.

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      Ugggh – sorry to hear about the two-year pining stint. It’s the worst feeling! But hopefully we learn something from it. And yes, I somehow don’t think its a coincidence that blogging has been negatively correlated to boyfriend…though you’d think it would open the pool significantly! I seriously do think I am married to my blog. I would be devastated if I had to be without it for any long period of time!

      • http://www.enteradulthood.com Diana Antholis

        Jenny & Amanda, 
        Don’t get mad at me for what I’m about to say (what a setup!)…but I do think that blogging could be repelling boyfriends…(and I have an example of how I’m a terrible girlfriend)

        If you are married to the blog, how are you going to be married to the boyfriend?  Guys like attention.  They want to feel special.  They want to know you will stop writing a blog post for a minute and pay attention to them.  JUST like us girls want the same exact thing.  

        Dating is hard, relationships are hard, SO much work has to go into it.

        They could also be scared of how out in the open the blog is…and want no part of it.

        That being said, smart, intelligent guys understand that your blog is your business and will appreciate your dedication to it.  Obviously those are the men you want to be with.  Unfortunately, that is hard to come by.

        Now I had been with my boyfriend for 3ish years when I started blogging, so he understood what it meant to my business.  SO on to my embarrassing story.  We always write each other “love” notes for special occasions, holidays, etc.  Sometimes just randomly.  I wrote him one for his birthday in May.  I was wondering why he didn’t say anything about it…so I asked.  He said,   “Honestly, it kind of sounded like a blog post.”  HOLY CRAP I felt like the biggest idiot on the face of the planet.  He said, “I know it was you & how you talk, but it wasn’t like how you normally write to me.”  After I kicked myself, I rewrote it, as his girlfriend, which made all the difference.  I’m glad he’s a patient and understanding guy.

        I feel like the lines can get blurred so easily.  But it’s really good to separate these things.  

        Has someone written about this already?  Blogging vs. Relationships?  I feel like someone has to.  Maybe we all should…

        • http://www.opheliaswebb.com Elisa Doucette

          Diana – I see your point, but now *I* feel like I’ve gotta chime in.  ;)

          I think that blogging is definitely a deterrent to potential boyfriends. But so is body type, hair color, clothes, career, family, political affiliation, religious choices…the list is  endless!! I’ve certainly met more than my fair share of guys that have admitted they would have been interested in dating me, but they were scared of the fact that I wrote for websites. This was especially an issue when I had the dating column!

          But I have also had guys who think it is purely awesome and pretty damn sexy that I have my blog and website and aspirations and career.

          There are many reasons to look at someone who obviously has as much to offer as Jenny and wonder “What is wrong…why isn’t she able to find a relationship?” In reality, there is a distinct possibility that she is doing a plethora or even a minute minimal amount of things that are deterring potential suitors. Or, she just hasn’t found the right person to be in a relationship with. She didn’t say she hasn’t been dating, just that she hasn’t found someone with whom she was able to make a serious relationship “go of things.”

          It seems to me, though, that for a relationship to really work out and be worth it, you need a partner that loves you and supports your passions and believes in you and the things that are important to you. Concessions and compromises need to be made in relationships, but to me it doesn’t seem like changing or giving up any of those should be one of them.

          I have totally fallen into the hazard of carrying work into the home (which, being a writer, sounds like happened to you) in both careers I have had. That is awesome that you and your boyfriend have an open enough communication channel and strong enough relationship to be able to frankly discuss it. And now you know for the future – less bloggy talk more girlfriend speak.  :)

          Still, pining for dreams and “could-be’s” isn’t good for anyone. Doesn’t make it any easier to stop doing it though.  :)

          • http://www.enteradulthood.com Diana Antholis

            Hi Elisa,
            Thanks for chiming in! ;)
            I am in no way trying to decipher the dating lives of anyone on this blog, comments, or in life, as you are correct, there are many other variables to take into account.  

            And as I said and you said, relationships are hard, compromises need to be made, and anyone who ever gives up something they love for “love” needs to evaluate the situation.

            I’m commenting on what Jenny said:  ”And yes, I somehow don’t think its a coincidence that blogging has been negatively correlated to boyfriend…though you’d think it would open the pool significantly!”

            I’m wondering what anyone’s experiences are with that statement.  Has anyone done research?  Had personal examples?  It sounds like you have…I’m curious about those guys you mentioned not wanting to date because of your columns, etc.  

            I think saying blogging is a deterrent to relationships is as broad as saying GenY is lazy…because there are so many other variables that affect the outcome.  But I am interested in the overall argument and people’s experiences with it.

  • http://twitter.com/FrenchyCaroline Caroline Mikolajczyk

    Hey Jenny!

    I don’t comment much here but i read every of your posts religiously. It’s amazing, i could have actually written this post (but again maybe a lot of women could have). I feel exactly the same, or maybe i should say I’m the same. I haven’t had a proper bf in 3/4 years now (very depressing), so i have virtual/brief crushes on people i haven’t even met, bloggers on the internet. ( i know, very pathetic..)

    I think i need to get out more and meet REAL people, but it’s not that easy when you work from home and don’t know that many people your age in town…

    Anyway, great post!! I hope we will all find the right guy one day :)

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      Hi Caroline! YAY!! So glad you stopped by to comment today, and so awesome that you’ve been reading for a while — THANK YOU!! It can be so easy to develop crushes over the Internet because we don’t have to deal with all the messiness of meeting and being with people in person – I totally get it! I’m hoping once I move to NYC I’ll be getting out of the house and meeting new people more. Cheers! Have a fabulous rest of your week :)

      • http://twitter.com/FrenchyCaroline Caroline Mikolajczyk

        My pleasure Jenny, absolutely love your site!!You are totally right, it’s easier to have an hypothetic relationship in our mind with someone who doesn’t really exist in our day-to-day world. I’m sure you will meet plenty of people in the Big Apple :) can’t wait to read your adventures!!

        Btw- i just started using your budget template, love love love!! :)

  • http://parisianfeline.wordpress.com Tatiana

    I feel bad because I can’t relate to you on many levels. I wish I could understand the concept of pining for another person in the way you’ve described in this post! But, I haven’t met anyone who I feel compatible with in that way, and among other factors, I tend to settle for imaginary relationships than trying to create real ones. But – I’m also a strong advocate for a life of permanent singleness and that I’d much rather be married to myself than anything external – metaphysically or not. 

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      Tatiana — consider it a good thing that you haven’t had this pining feeling! I hear you on settling for relationships based on the idea — one day, when it’s right, you’ll know it (oy — never thought I’d be giving out that lame cliche — ignore me!). Suffice it to say that I’m with you — I’d rather be married to myself ANY day than unhappy in a relationship. Thanks for stopping by!

  • http://17000-days.com Cara Stein

    Wow, I so needed this two years ago! I was a hundred kinds of obsessed with this guy who was clearly not that into me and not even good for me. My rational side was very clear on why it would never work and why I didn’t want to keep thinking about him, but it was like a fever or something. I just couldn’t stop! In the end, it was his indifference and annoyingness that saved me–after awhile, that eclipsed all the breathless chemicals or whatever cursed thing is to blame for this stuff. Meanwhile, my diary from that time is hilarious. (“Still wasting energy thinking about X…”)

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      “A hundred kinds of obsessed” — LOL! It’s amazing how our rational side can have ALL the facts, be SO clear, and yet our pharamone/limerant/etc side can be like a train on the tracks — nothing will stop it from moving forward. I hear you on the melancholy diary entries too! Only funny in hindsight, only funny in hindsight ;-)

      Thanks so much for stopping by, Cara!! So happy that we met this year — and even happier that we’ve kept in touch :)

      • http://17000-days.com Cara Stein

        Actually, I was amazed at how aware the diary entries were. I was viewing myself objectively enough that I’m pretty sure a lot of them were funny at the time, too. :) It was a weird time for me–just recovering from a disaster of a marriage, and going through a whiplash-inducing series of short-lived crushes. By the time I got to this one, I knew the drill. It was just more painful than the others because the guy was doing enough partial reinforcement that I kept thinking he might be interested in me, even though he obviously wasn’t in any real way. 
        Anyway, definitely glad to know you, too! WDS buds ftw! :)

  • http://alexisgrant.com Alexis Grant

    Ah. The pining. Sadly, I feel you! It’s such a good rush. Seriously though, you are SUCH A CATCH. I look forward to reading the post about The Right Guy :)

    Also, thanks for linking to your designer — Always looking for good Thesis designers! Can’t wait to see what she does for you.

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      Thanks Alexis!! I love it — The Right Guy — will be very curious to know how and when that post comes about for sure :)

      As for Nina — I’m OBSESSED!! Well not in a creepy way, just in a “she’s a total rockstar and you can’t go wrong” kind of way! I highly recommend getting in touch with her if you’re looking for a redesign :)

      • http://alexisgrant.com Alexis Grant

        I’m putting her on my list! I often have clients and friends who need a Thesis designer.

  • Jeremy Johnson

    You’re a great story teller. I could picture you going through each step as you described it. Thought I’d chime in here from a guys perspective (for whatever that is worth :) ).

    From what I’ve seen from you, you have all the makings of someone special – someone who is inherently driven to succeed and help others. You keep yourself in good physical condition and live a healthy lifestyle. You’re enthusiastic and continuously improving. Whatever guy ends up catching your eye better be on his A game and then some.

    Not sure if this helps, but as a guy, I can tell you that from what I’ve seen, you are one of the keepers and you should have no problem attracting someone who matches your many excellent qualities.

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      Jeremy – this comment put a huge smile on my face…THANK YOU! Your guy’s perspective is very much appreciated :) I always value seeing myself through someone else’s eyes — your comments and kind words mean a lot. And without trying to advise or “fix” — that’s a fine line to walk! Thanks for taking the time to write, and for being such an awesome part of the LAC community :)

  • Sudangautam

    Hey Jenny! I was reading your book “life after college”. could you help me with this question/
    What 3 specific actions could you take to improve your life balance?  page 60 being specific.
    I couldn’t get this question. Please help me out so that i could move ahead.

  • http://twitter.com/financialsamura Financial Samurai

    Hey Jenny,

    Unfortunately, he probably found someone else.  Guys are just like that.  They are courteous and kind and make you think they like you.  If they really do, they will be ALL OVER you on the phone, texting, flying over to see you etc.  Guys have no shame in that regard.  I really suggest moving on.

    Have a read of this post.  It’s on topic and something you might find interesting: http://www.financialsamurai.com/2011/08/12/hot-sexy-super-picky-and-still-single-over-30/

    Sam

  • http://socialhospitality.com Debbie Miller

    LOVED this! I am the EXACT same way. I haven’t had actually dated anyone in 4 hours, due to extreme busy-ness and pickiness, and having chemistry with someone is so RARE, and when it happens like how you described, I get hooked, then pine. What’s great about your story, even though this part also sucks, is that you were able to identify the “he’s just not that into you signs”, and work toward getting over him rather than getting deeper and deeper involved, and THEN noticing, and getting burnt even worse.

  • http://habbala.com Habbala

    I mean OF COURSE there’s a pining prevention template.  I love you so much it is actually obscene.  

  • http://livingonimpulse.com Markus

    Here’s something to try on. This isn’t necessarily true, just an exercise in looking from a different perspective. Let’s pretend that what attracted you to him was something that somewhere along the timeline of your life you suppressed in yourself. Ask your greater self for what that might be, maybe before bedtime and spend a few moments inside of that question (without immediately answering it). Be more interested in the question than the answer.

    …perhaps something that needed to be suppressed in order to get the other things you were looking for in life (at the time). Let’s imagine that it wasn’t him that you saw, but an undeniable reflection of something in yourself that once you knew to be true and live, that hasn’t quite been so lately.

    once you know the answer, spend at least some part of the next day breathing life into that very thing in yourself.

    Perhaps he was just a reminder of who you are

  • http://twitter.com/JazzyJasminA Jasmin A

    this template is GENIUS

    • http://www.lifeaftercollege.org jennyblake

      Thanks so much Jasmin!! Thrilled that you’re finding it helpful — let me know if you think of any questions to add!

Previous post:

Next post: